STEVE HARVEY ON HAVING BIG IDEAS
The Dell Community has contributed: 9422 ideas | promoted 644152 times | 72141 comments

How IdeaStorm Works:

Post Promote Discuss See
67550

Stripped down, fast Linux Box

67550 points posted to Accessories (Keyboards, etc.), Desktops, Linux by pawprintz 02/17/07 **REVIEWED**

How about a fast, Internet ready Linux desktop. Small form factor, pretty monitor, mouse & keyboard, the O.S., OpenOffice & Firefox. Cheap'n'fast


Dell sees the value of this idea, and is keeping the sugestions for a Linux small form factor on the radar. john_h will let the community know of any new information as it comes.




forworldpeace
02/17/07
We're talking serious heat here but this option may only be viable for the tech savvy... your mom who just wants a computer to email and surf the net is better off with a tested product that works without glitches...

For me, I'd take the linux option without thinking of the repercussions
voxpelli
02/17/07
A linux customized for just mailing, surfing the net and write some documents can be made much easier than Windows. You can give your mom exactly the options she knows how to handle and have all the other options premade and hidden.

This would be a really good thing because what linux lacks most at the moment is the support of a computermaker - the technology is there.
spook
02/20/07
For those not 'trained' into the Windows way, using KDE / GNOME is no harder by default. If the GUI was stripped down to the basic functions : Kmail, Open Office, Firefox, then it would be WAY better than anything else for Grandma.
greg123
02/20/07
I'd just love to see Dell offer a computer/configuration with "ready for Linux" or something similar.My cousin likes Linux much more then Windows lately. She used MAC before but now that she discovered Beryl and there is now way out :) I have to prepare her scripts to install stuff but she can manage most of the tasks alone. By the way she likes KDE. The only problem is searching for right hardware and creating scripts for installing certain programs from Internet in Ubuntu. I'd love to get Linux pre- installed on computer because this takes too much time to get it right sometimes. The other problem is searching for right hardware like web cam that works on linux and making scripts to install and configure drivers from Internet. She has 4 friends with same hardware and all I have to do to install webcam on others computers is to send them script on email and they click on that script and webcam is working. It's that simple.What I'd love to see is to get supported hardware from Dell. Linux is very much like OS-X mac. When you have right hardware configuration it just works. That's why I'd love to get a linux ready computer with a tag that tells me that in my computer store. They don't want to buy from internet. I know there is a option. I don't wanna search annoying forums and beg linux enthusiasts to tell me the best hardware configuration and then putting together the best computer to suit my need. Is such a big problem to make a sticker to tell me if your configuration works with linux ? Pls since beryl I'm putting together 2 linux machines / month. And it gets worse with laptops !! Some of her friends/parents still need windows. I'd love to get dual boot machines preinstalled too.
oldschool
02/20/07
DELL DESIGNERS **PLEASE LOOK HERE*** Just take a look at http://www.cappuccinopc.com/ Cappuccino Pcs

These little Linux-compatible computers (often fanless) are amazing. It's time for Dell to go SMALL and COOL. Think blue LEDs, futuristic design. Out-Mac the Mac, and power it with Linux. The lines will stretch around the block if the price is right...
drnoelkelly
02/21/07
I think this is a genuinely good idea. A lot of people want simplicity and just the basics and it looks good and is slient too then all the better.

A machine that is presented with simply a browser (firefox) and OpenOffice on a clean and attractive Linux desktop would sell well. The customer can forget about all the nasty viruses and spyware and enjoy something simple, relatively safe and reliable.
tara
02/23/07
Since Windows Vista I see a lot of people getting interested in Linux.
Me too, recently a friend of mine convinced me of installing Linux.
Since Dell is my favorite brand of computers, delivering perfect systems(except for the windows on them :D),
I tried to install a linux on my Dell Dimension 9150, I'm having a lot of trouble trying to install it.
SO SUMMARY: Dell with a Linux-distro pre-installed on it = A TOTAL UBER-SYSTEM!!!
oldschool
02/24/07
tara - please try different Linux live CDs to see which runs best on your 9150. Have a look at this thread, where someone has successfully installed SUSE 10.0 on their 9150:

http://slforums.typo3-factory.net/lofiversion/index.php/t38655.html

Try the Live CDs for:

PCLinuxOS
Vector Linux
Linux Mint

One of those should work. If you're still not having any joy, please post at www.linuxforums.com

Good luck!

tonyalfrey
02/27/07
Merged Idea originally posted 02/17/07
linux laptop

Sell a laptop with linux in which everything works.
1. Select a distro.
2. Work with the packager of the distro to make sure that you've selected components for the laptop that have all the necessary drivers.
3.. Develop a tight working relationship with the packager of the distro so that they have some sense that you're in it for the long haul.
4. Provide a service contract through the packager of the distro for support on the software.
5. Work with the packager of the distro to keep the distro/laptop functional, so that stupid kernel updates don't break the system.
6. Make it idiot proof like a Mac.
christophe.dr
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/19/07
No more dsdt programmed only for windows !!! Linux and OSS compatibility is a duty for every hardware vendor !
amaroker
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/19/07
Farfetched, shallow, and unreasonable. Especially 5 and 6. Especially 6.
levinch
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/19/07
Linux is easy.
I use linux since 3 years with no problem.
But i need to work a little bit, not du to the system, but to find a computer.
Today i'ma working on a Mac.
I dell propose all its computer with the opportunity of linux, i'll buy a Dell.
xanadu
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/19/07
Notebook purchase in the next 30 days

I have been looking for a notebook to install Linux Ubuntu on. I don't need Windows and I don't want to pay for something that I will not be using. Dell hardware has an excellent reputation but the threat of buying a computer that may not be fully functional in Linux keeps my away from an internet purchase. I would rather buy a Dell, but why should I pay for an operating system that I will not be using.
Give us the option to have Ubuntu pre-installed or have no system installed and let us install lLnux ourselves
danny.wall
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/19/07
1) Work with hardware vendors to get drivers for Linux, on all models, especially power management.
2) Make all models of laptops and PCs available with a No OS option, and a Linux (top 3 is a good idea) option. And these options SHOULD cost less than Windows since Linux is cheaper than Windows, and the distributors of Linux will support the OS of choice. Obviously, a No OS option should be the cheapest.

I see no reason why a hardware vendor would limit their customer base by not having Linux drivers. There are more installations of Linux than Mac, and more everyday. If the development of Linux drivers is not something they do well, outsource or open source, and they will get created. Open source drivers are preferred.

There is also no reason why Dell should not offer a No OS option on every single piece of hardware they sell. This works for anyone that currently owns their own OS (Retail Mac x86, Retail or Corporate purchased Linux, BSD, FreeDOS, existing Retail/Corporate/Strong Arm Windows purchase, etc). Again, there is also no reason to make this cost more than a Windows version of the same hardware. Even if Microsoft is giving kickbacks like Intel, the cost of testing, configuring the hardware, purchasing and configuring the hardware for duplication, and supporting Windows on your hardware has to cost more than a No OS option that needs no software support. And don't let Microsoft give you that piracy BS. People want choice, and the choice is almost always Linux or BSD over pirated Windows.
toebee
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/19/07
Dell DOES offer some "Open source" notebooks. They come without an OS installed an a Freedos install kit. Certainly not quite to the level proposed here as far as support goes but it is a start I guess.

http://www.dell.com/content/products/features.aspx/nseries_nb?s=bsd
jimmarch
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
All the ideas reagarding this are thrashed out in the "main" Linux thread.

The main reason this is an even better idea on a laptop is that the number of people into hardcore gaming on laptops are even lower than on desktops. Or to put it another way: there are laptop buyers with just NO interest in gaming period. Those are a big part of your market.

You'll have to make sure WiFi is pre-sorted and if you're smart, you'll also offer something with onboard EVDO as well (with the Linux driver issues solved). EVDO under Linux is doable but it's a pain to get it running the first time...Dell can of course eliminate that problem in short order.
jimmarch
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
As to no-OS options:

Once Dell has set up Linux for a given system, laptop OR desktop, the cost to install it to a hard disk is trivial. They have to format the drive anyways; the same process that formats can write a disk image to it. There's really no reason to have a no-OS option. Unless of course Dell ends up having to charge about $15 a pop or so for MP3 and DVD/DIVX codecs...hmmm...which they might strongly want to consider...
knutt
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
Yes, please! I have a Dell Dimension that I dual boot using an external USB drive. It is fun (but oh, so frustrating!) to set it up so that Linux works 100%. So far my main headache is the wireless...
wolverine
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
Hi all,

I bought a DELL D620 last July with NO-OS option. So it was already possible to ask DELL to remove their "recommended OS". I installed a Slackware 11.0 whereas they didn't know if the hardware will be recognized ... So I think that people at DELL support are not able to support in details all Linux distros even the major distros ( RH, Suse, Mandriva, debian ...) because they don't have any training on that OS. And it will be very complicated for them to support all hardware, without the help of the Linux community ...

But everything is possible with Linux ... :) !!!

carlo
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
There are many informatic specialists that convert their win-based laptop into linx-based laptop, but frequently facing configuration problems (display, sound, wifi,...).
topillo
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
I want a Dell linux laptop
cellarmation
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
I would buy a dell linux laptop, it would be nice if you could request dual boot aswell
dki
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
Next year I start to study. If there is a Linux Notebook available (enought is only "Linux Ready" and no installed OS) buy Dell, I will by it directly.

I think their are enough experts for Linux-maschines available. Their is no problem to find somebody!
sukw
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
I own a Dell Latitude D600 running Ubuntu 7.04. The community support for Dell is already quite good, but it would just be great if it would be possible to buy a notebook or desktop already shipped with Linux.
A few months ago we decided to set up a own computer pool with some scientific software ( I'm a scientist at a technical university). We wanted to have Linux on the system due the the scientific software ( e.g. octave ) and there were no hardware out there who could deliver us just desktops with preinstalled Linux. I hope so much next time we can just order it at dell.com/de
icicle
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
If you offer a Inspiron with Ubuntu my choice for my next notebook will be DELL!!!
For me its that simple.
carlosponti
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
i would love a no OS laptop or Linux Laptop. i absolutely would be interested. currently you cant home build a laptop. i have to buy old used laptops and put linux on them. Use a popular Distro for ease of installation.
carlosponti
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
site problems caused duplication
liamjames91
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
i bought a toshiba satellite laptop, first thing i did was get rid of windows and install ubuntu (which i knew would work fine with wireless internet since the intel centrino wireless chipset) everything works perfectly!!(luckily i may add) but i would have definately gone for dell though, having the reasurance that everything was already setup and working would have been a much better choice! btw desktops with linux preinstalled are available on ebay, just search for ubuntu, theyre really reasonable prices! if dell did preinstalled linux laptops they would definately be my choice next time i need to buy a laptop!!
afterall IBM have just invested $1billion dollars in linux !!!
tw04l124
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
Yes I want such hardware, without any microsoft hardware, please
jantman
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
I don't care about service and support, or idiot-proof-ness. I'm a programmer and a SysAdmin. I just want to buy a laptop from Dell, not some custom manufacturer, where they will tell me that "Everything on this laptop is guaranteed to work with the following distributions: ..."

I don't even want it pre-installed, I just want Dell to tell me that it will work with openSuSE 10.2, RedHat xxx, and whatever other distros.
thx84
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
some hardware can be a pain in the ass to install(webcams are a good example). it would be great if really everything could work out of the box. linux has come a long way already, but i think it could gain more people if it was hassle-free
weirdo
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
I'd really buy a Linux laptop.

Last year, I was looking for a Linux laptop (or at least a brand new laptop without Windows preinstalled), but to no avail. So I had to buy a desktop computer, built by myself.

Also, if sometime Dell offers Linux-based laptops, it would be great if they sell (or ship) them worldwide, not just the US, Canada and (sometimes) Europe.
shrewduser
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
If dell sold a linux laptop then a Dell would be my next laptop purchase.
alberto
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/20/07
I'd like a laptop with no microsoft tax on it. i work with ubuntu.
warner
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I want to add that it is not important that dell offers multiple distros, it's important that they offer computers with hardware support in the mainline kernel. Doing this will ensure that a user can run *any* distro.

They could make their install image very lean, focused simply on functioning hardware and the main applications that every one has come to expect (office suite, web browser, im client, anti virus (unnecesary), and support just that. Users are then free to add as much other *unsupported* software as they want, just as is the case now. Practicaly speaking Dell's support requirements on a basic Foss bundle will probably be *far* lower than an MS bundle. If anyone doubts this ask someone on the front line of a mixed os helpdesk.

They could easily partner with RedHat, Ubuntu/Canonical, Suse. I actualy think Ubuntu/Canonical is the best choice as their main product is also free. I'm sure Canonical & the Ubuntu community would bend over backwards to assist in hardware validation and support

As far as Linux drivers go The Linux kernel team has made a formal offer to *create* and *maintain* a Linux driver *for free* for *any* hardware manufacurer. There is an incredible level of desire to offer *free* assistance to the hardware and computer OEMs by the Free and Open Source communities, both in terms of hardware and end-user support.

Link to the Linux kernel teams formal offer of free hardware support.

http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/free_drivers.html
http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/free_drivers_faq.html
bugmenot
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I bought one DELL Inspiron 5 years ago. I had it fixed six or seven times since, having been disappointed I haven't planned buying one again. I loathed the preinstalled Windows XP Home image, which I considered just crappy (not mentioning the additional applications installed!).

However, offering models bundled with a Linux distribution like (K)Ubuntu is in fact a good reason to reassess my opinion about the Inspiron series. I think, I could imagine buying such a model - provided that it's cheaper than a comparable notebook with Vista.
scmjsd
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
i had some dell flyers put through my letter box, these included very cheap laptops which come with windows. however as al inux user i refuse to pay for something i don't want. therefore i phoned the sales line and had a protracted conversation... i could not even get the laptop without windows installed. the indian guy informed me i can only get the high end laptops without an OS, and that was my only option if i don't want windows. i dont' really care if it comes preinstalled with linux or not, since it is free anyway it doesn't make much difference to me. anyway, subsequently i sent an email to the sales team in the uk, explaining i would like a dell laptop either with linux or with no OS. they ignored my email. i think the laptop situation is more severe as one can always build their own desktop pc, but with a laptop you really are 100% forced the windows route for pc architecture. come on dell, listen to us!
ioannis
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
It's all about delivering laptops that work with Linux out-of-the box, either by choosing hardware vendors that already support Linux or working with them and the Linux community to develop drivers for them.

thanks warner for pointing this out. Let me repeat it here. The linux kernel community offers free linux driver development for any hardware vendor interested! :
http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/free_drivers.html
http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/free_drivers_faq.html

there is no excuse!
pead23
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
@warner: I totally agree. The key issue to proper linux support (or freebsd or whatever) is to have free drivers in the standard kernel. That is, the drivers should be open-sourced under GPL. Dell doesn't have to write the drivers themselves but they should provide the specs. Binary drivers (as they are provided by many companies) are just as restricting as any other proprietary software: you depend on the manufacturer, and if he decides to stop linux support then you either have to buy new hardware or you cannot upgrade your operating system.
giammy
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I already have a Dell laptop and almost everything works with linux:
a little bit to say that EVERYTHING works with Linux!
(and do not pay a windows licence that one does not use!)
luc
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I think it would be a great business idea for dell people, to develop an option like this, not only because of the obvious price-drop; you could actually compete with mac (and others) in his territory (that is trust, my friends). So you see, you are not selling computers, you are selling trust and security. In the way you are keeping Microsoft busy in order to not slam you with their prices.
jss167
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I agree with offering several Linux distros as options, as well as OpenOffice. I have been using Linux for a long time, while being able to do everything everyone else can. I would also like to see Dell list what Windows and the other MS products actually cost. They cannot be free to the user, they are bundled into the price. Another issue of concern, is how Vista has digital rights management, so that you may not be able to do what you think you can. There is a lot of this news on the Web. I wish to be able to use my computer in the manner of my choice, after all, I bought it!
lbai
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I'll vote for this if the laptop comes with only F/OSS supported hardware. A machine with ATI/nVidia hardware, or Broadcom/ndiswrapper wifi is a non-starter for me.

I also don't buy laptops without an RS-232 serial port because I use it to support Cisco hardware and I don't want to have to carry a USB dongle around everywhere. I really don't see why RS-232 has disappeared from most laptops (cmon, 9 pins isn't that big).

And what's especially important for a laptop is getting Suspend2 to work correctly.
gdhmr
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
If you make sure that your linux laptop has all the drivers up and running in linux I would switch from buying apple laptops to buying Dell. Number 5 and 6 are especially good ideas.
kejava
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
Been using Linux on laptops for about 6 years now. The headaches for me are:
1) ACPI power management: sleep and hibernation. Dells (all laptops) have broken DSDTs. Please fix them.
2) Better video support direct rendering / acceleration.
3) Wireless (WPA, WPA2, etc) that doesn't require proprietary firmware.

Honestly, I can work around items 2 and 3. It's item 1 that concerns me. Fix the damn DSDTs!!!
jack.ripoff
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
Dell could make a deal with a major Linux distributor (e.g. Novell, Red Hat, Mandriva) like they to with Microsoft.
frednerk
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
amoroker, you are bordering on trolling. There is no supporting evidence (i.e. you haven't provided it) for your argument. If you have tried any linux, it was probably red hat back in 1998 and things have changed since then (I bought and immediately returned Win 98 First Ed, because of how poor it was).

As many users have pointed out - there are many people willing to give free, any driver that's required. Saying it is ridiculous to think that we can get a secure linux laptop operational, is silly and ignores the fact that Windows laptops break (frequently). My wife stuffed her Win Xp laptop in 2 months. 6 months after installing ubuntu, it still works perfectly.

She wants a new laptop in a year or two. I will not buy her one unless it comes with either a linux distro or non-os option available. If Dell offers it, Dell gets my cash. Simple
limerat
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
If Dell starts offering Linux pre-loaded machines with Linux-friendly printers,Dell has my $$$.
(Freespire Linux user.)
lesleyb
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
SuSE

Put SuSE on it

:)

Please
drcrane
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I bought an Inspiron 6400 about 6 months ago. Almost everything works fine with my chosen distribution (Ubuntu 6.10 currently) except for graphics. The laptop comes with an ATI chipset that is not properly supported by open source X drivers. My resolution is 1024x768 instead of 1200x800.

I could find a driver on ATI's site probably but I have no interest in doing so and having my video break when I apply security patches for the kernel or X.

My next laptop (I expect I'll buy a new one within the next 12 months) will be better researched and if the laptop will not run at optimal resolution without hunting for drivers then that is not a laptop that I will buy - most intel graphics chipsets work ok, ATI does not. I must say though that the majority of things work great (no problems with sound, wireless, touchpad or even the funky buttons on the front.

Having Linux pre-installed is not an issue for me. I erase Windows, install Linux, end of story. But if Dell went the extra step and integrated things like firmware-tools and functional hardware monitoring then that would be a definite plus. For a company as large as Dell supporting a few popular Linux distributions by way of apt and yum repositories should be a drop in the bucket ... do it and you will be keeping my money in the future as well.
emksuse
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
Back in October I purchased an HP notebook as it was easy to get and appeared to work with opensuse. Had Dell supported a linux notebook, then I probably would have purchased the Dell.
wcmozart
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I agree -- around 3 yrs ago at a Linux expo in NYC I approached 2-4 Linus vendors and asked them to pick A FEW (ie 2-4) good laptops and work with the manufacturers to GUARANTEE that their distribution would install properly and without problem on these SELECTED laptops -- to no avail. I'm somewhat of an amateur, and need a very good desktop with an excellent compliment of office apps - about 18 months ago, my last fling with LINUX (I try every 24 months or so) was when I bought an HP DV1000 and tried to install SuSe on it -- too many problems (never did get the modem to work, took one week of effort to get the printer to work because of a SuSe documentation error, the mouse pad worked but not all the features .. and it is still screwed up because the repartitioning tools were only one way -- from NTFS to LINUX, and not back again, so if you made a mistake and had to shrink LINUX partitions and expand NTFS partitions -- NO WAY. Plus the office apps didnt work either (talk about buggy software), and the fonts were still krap (but thats an extremely old problem that may never be solved)
mylilalien
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I don't ask for anything too fancy, just a laptop where all components work out of the box with a modern Linux distro (Fedora/SuSE/Ubuntu). I have not had trouble for years with my desktops/laptops/servers being fully functional using Linux, but if I drop $1,000 on a laptop I want the manufacturer to certify it is fully functional with Linux.
jcli57
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/21/07
I have just bought a laptop, and would have bought it at dell if they provided a range with linux (preferably kubuntu in my case) installed.
gmcr
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
great idea. I really want it
darkelve
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
I love the idea of a laptop with Linux pre-installed. Personally I would prefer a laptop with either OpenSuSe 10.2/10.3 on it + proprietary codecs and multimedia support, or Unbtu Edgy Eft/Feisty Fawn + proprietary codecs and multimedia support. On my desktop I installed it myself (dual-boot), but for laptops it is just too much hassle and too much risk for an end-user.

Dealmaker/breaker, is of course full support for hardware: wireless, bluetooth, full 3D accelleration for XGL/AIXGL, suspend, ... there already exist companies which create Linux laptops, for example http://system76.com/ .

Support on hardware parts and maybe even software would be great, Dell could work with the distribution vendors and in case of known bugs push out priority updates. Or give customized support options so you can cater to each category.

And if possible, make it cost less than the same laptop with Windows preloaded!

I'm looking out for a laptop myself, and Linux is a very good match for laptops, if all the HW is compatible, but as far as I know, there are no companies in Europe selling those. And the ease-of-mind of having my Linux laptop & software (at least, the OS) supported by a company with good reputation, would be a big plus. And of course not to forget the distribution channel, so that I can easily obtain it.

pierrec
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
hello,
Ilnux offers possibility to be on a laptop if Dell offer the choice before buying I definitely will take it .
cheers
dave_of_oz
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
Very good news indeed.

I for one have never bought a new laptop for the simple reason that do not want to pay for software that I am not going to use, ( MS Windows).

It would be even better if Dell joined the campaign for improved linux drivers, not only for laptops but for desktop systems as well.
jhabbers
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
I really like this idea. I like Dell hardware. The server i bought of them a year and half ago has run without any problems at all and was beautiful designed. I have however personally never bought a Dell laptop and the primary reason is that I get so annoyed with the "Dell recommends insert latest version of Windows here" plastered all over their website. The server I could get without Windows preinstalled, if I could get a Dell laptop without Windows, having it preinstalled with a Linux distro working out of the box would be a great bonus, I would buy one.
drahnreb
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
i have 2 DELL Inspiron Laptops (9200 and 6000). I would be glad, when they we being offerd with a linux OS!
gx7777
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
Yup. This one is a hands-down winner for techies.. the same folks who recommend systems to buy for themselves and others to the corporate big-wigs who ask because they don't know.

Hello, Dell?
pj
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
I have no reason to use my Dell with Linux OS. Linux is only OS, no more. It's not a corporate OS (may be, exept SuSE). I can use Firefox, OOo, Thunderbird, GIMP in Windows as well as in Linux. If you can buy Latitude D620 for 1800$ approx, the 140$ WinXP OEM is not so hard for you budget, isn't it?
mmaki
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
Ahhhh.......but if you are never going to use Windows and want the Dell hardware why pay the $140 for it. Give me $140 break and hardware compatible with Linux.
crom
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
Yea I think the driver issue is important, and I think ubuntu is probably the best choice as a distro to use. I've already purged XP on an older Dell laptop I have and run Ubuntu. I love it.
simonkossen
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
Mandriva-2007 works very well on a Dell-Inspiron-9400. Only linux drivers for Dell All-in-One Printers (i.e. Dell-Photo-944) are missing.
ordnancemarine
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
As a matter of fact, I just purchased a Dell E1705 and after chatting for nearly 30 minutes with a sales rep they could not tell me if it was linux compatible, I specifically asked if it had Broadcomm drivers or Intel Drivers for the wireless card and the sales rep couldn't answer. I took my chances and bought it. Well, it had the broadcom drivers and even with NDIS wrapper I have only found one distro that I could get it to work on. I didn't buy the no-OS laptops because a 17 inch screen was not offered and I still need to run windoze for 1 application. (secure web mail not supported though firefox). The SD card reader didn't work in Linux either. So, now I am dual booting but still wish the pre-installed Linux were an option.
randavance
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
I definitely like this idea, I'm having dreams of seeing a white laptop with some sort of Dell+Tux logo on the front and a crisp screen running Ubuntu. Instead of the Windows key a tux key too. Theres a growing population of Linux users out there and it would be great to see Dell make a move twords the new market. I personally run Linux alone on my Dell in only 256Mb RAM.

Definitely Linux compatible hardware would be nice. I've always had trouble with my non-Dell DVD burner (but then again Windows did too, infact it would crash every time I tried to burn something).
viperash
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
There is no reason why Dell is holding off on offering linux on its Laptops. I Intend to eventually buy the precision series and immediately install Linux on it
dphurst
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/22/07
I'm tired of binary programs and drivers that I have to pay for. Aren't you?

I think Dell's corporate will quickly understand the software world has changed dramatically since open source software has become the new path. The hardware guys that "get it" will still be around in the 10 years. Those that don't, won't. It's pretty simple, really.

It is Linux based hardware driving the server market. We are seeing the desktop/laptop market growing now. It won't take 10 more years, it is happening now. Note that it is those without an entrenched IT base that are moving right now. It is fascinating to watch those with lesser resources take advantage of the open source world. Those with lesser resources are actually a larger base of users/businesses than those that currently have the major IT in place. Look at China, India, all of Africa, it is huge what is happening with open source in those countries. All this speaks toward a move by Dell to expand it's markets with open source based hardware. I'd rather sell a billion Linux laptops to the rest of the world while selling 100 million Windows laptops to North America and Europe than just the 100 million to North America and Europe.
stephan
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/23/07
I am also running linux on two Dell Laptops. I had a hard time configuring both of them because there was just very little information on how to set up the system. I nearly came to the point where i thought it was just not possible to setup Linux on my Dell. Now everything is working fine but it would be great to have a preconfigured Linux System where all the Hardware is working just fine.
dsbcjb
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/23/07
With Ubuntu and Freespire now working together that is going to only make their disros stronger and Dell would be Smart to get behind them. I purchased a toshiba a couple months ago but definately go Dell if they would get behind this.
guyjohnston
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/24/07
I'd like to see Dell selling a laptop with GNU/Linux preinstalled, particularly the gNewSense distribution, as it's 100% free as in freedom (see http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/) If you'd also like to see it preinstalled, please vote for the idea to do so at http://www.dellideastorm.com/article/show/63082/Preinstall_gNewSense_on_lapto... .
whitehomebrew
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/24/07
you lost my recent purchase of a laptop to www.system76.com
barry5280
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/24/07
I have read a lot of die hard linux users say how much they want all open source or nothing. I myself and probably like most others that are starting to experiment with Linux. I like the option of using Flash Player, configuring my Nvidia graphics card etc. I just want a computer that works and software that works on it. I have my Dell XPS M140 setup with PCLinuxOS and I like some of the options they have included on thier latest release, because my wireless card works, graphics card works, sound works and all without much configuration. I do think there is a happy middle point. Use the top 10 distributions and let the users pick. If you like 100% open source fine, if you want more of a Freespire approach that's fine too. Just allow us all to choose something other than the latest "flawed" version of Windows. "Dell Choice" would be a good option.
devlin
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/24/07
My wife and I left Windows behind last year. As our machines are aging I'd love to be able to buy off-the-shelf linux box's by a reputable name brand company. One important point.... I don't want one like I've seen offered at other places where their only linux alternatives are just machines to get rid of old hardware with. I want current and powerful processors, decent size hard drives. In other words if you are going to charge me close to a Windows system price I want a close to Windows spec. machine! None of this Celeron/Sempron w/ 512MB RAM and 80GB HD at the same price as the Athlon 64 x2's w/ 1GB, 160GB HD's w/ Windows. If you don't do it and HP or another top 5 manufacture does...Guess where my $$$ is going...
sswartzl
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/24/07
You used to sell Linux laptops. I have a Dell Inspiron 7500 purchased in 2000 that had Red Hat Linux preinstalled on it. You stopped selling them after a short time, and I've always wondered why. You included the full install media, and also a complete guide on how to reinstall it. It was a fine machine. I still have it.
dirge
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/24/07
I need to buy a laptop in the coming months, though I would defer my purchase if Dell were to offer Linux pre-installed. I expect it to work out of the box just as a Mac or Windows machine would. I hope to see one soon.
valeryan_24
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/25/07
Dell should consider to offer other options than Windows to its customers, although the pressures from Microsoft and reductions given for keeping its monopole.

It would be great if Dell could cooperate with companies like Canonical for Ubuntu, to provide laptops well adapted to Linux.
cocopunk
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/25/07
I am already an dell laptop owner, I wasn't sure to buy an dell laptop because I was obliged to get it with windows !
I decide to buy it finally because Inspiron 6400 is nice and your PC are very customizable, I'm really "happy" with this laptop because I've installed Ubuntu without big problems, but some little constructors sell PC with linux inside, so please don't oblige me to get my future PC (mine and for my family : father, mother and friends) in an other constructor.

When I received your "satisfaction survey", I already send my opinion about linux in your PC.

I'm not a geek, I began with Ubuntu one year ago, I think it's really easy to use some "user-friendly" linux distributions the great problem is the drivers for some materials. It will be fantastic if you product laptop and classic PC with linux or without operating system but perfectly compatible with some distributions (Ubuntu, Fedora, OpenSUSE are good choices I think).

It's important that you stop to sell everytimes windows with your PC (for home I mean) more and more person don't want to use this OS, so they paid for something they won't use ! Personnaly, it's made me angry.

I really hope that Dell will apply these ideas about linux and stop to buy everytimes windows with PC.

If I made some mistakes in this comment I'm sorry, but I'm french.
redar
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
我想买个linux的本本,dell大叔加油了!!!~~~
stgermain
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
I like the idea, but then I hope the internal wifi card will work out of the box. I not a linux geek and I still have to work with a wired connection on my linux laptop.
krifon
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
I also miss Linux (eg. openSUSE) on DEL-Laptops!
mrlinux11
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
Well reading the link below, it appears Dell is just paying lip service to this Ideas or doesnt understand what pre-installed means
http://direct2dell.com/one2one/archive/2007/02/23/6868.aspx#comments
mrlinux11
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
Well Dell if this is the best you can do for your most popular idea, you should shut down this site, because all it does is alienate all of your customers, whether they want Linux or not, they see you doing nothing on this issue, which makes the site look like sham.
shrewduser
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
firstly Mr linux give it a few days at least... then submit a new suggestion, tell them that their lucklustre linux support sucks and we want more... i know i'd vote for more....
yesmathew
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
Crap. I do not trust Dell providing pre-installed Linux. http://www.dellideastorm.com/article/show/63835
gurfink
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
I WANT A LINUX LAPTOP.
Build a decent, stable, powerful enough for home use including video editing Linux laptop for CAD 600 or 700, and you've got yourselves a new customer.
dgoryunov
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
IMHO, not all the suggestion would work, but if there would be at least a complete set of drivers supporting all of the hardware and featured of the Dell notebook, I would be happy. Also it would be nice if corresponding drivers would be available on dell support web site.
mrlinux11
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
Reply to shrewduser, The website has been up since Feb 16th and this has been one of the most popular options since the start and a week later this was the best they could come up with in a week. There is no preinstalled anything but Windows, even with the FreeDos option you have to install it !!!!!
hackamore
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
I wonder how much the linux "packager" will charge for a full hand holding service contract for an OS written by amateurs in their spare time?
but then again who needs pre-packaged drivers anyway, any real linux geek would just write his/her own drivers and then give them away.
marx2k
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
@hackamore
If you'd read earlier int he thread...
The linux kernel community offers free linux driver development for any hardware vendor interested! :
http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/free_drivers.html
http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/free_drivers_faq.html
cyberscan
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
I agree with the above posters. Last year, I shop on Dell's website. I even called to ask about getting a home computer with Linux. That was a no go - Dell wouldn't do it. What I ended up doing is building my own computer, downloading drivers, and tweaking Linux to work with the hardware. Yes, Linux can be tedious to install, but it's worth it because of its stability, free software, and security. I have used Linux since 94, and I do not want to go back to Windows unless Microsoft stops with all of their anti-piracy countermeasures, DRM, and exorbitant pricing. Most of these things hurts honest consumers rather than thwart piracy.

Dell can take several different Linux distributions and tweak them so that they install on each particular machine without a hitch. This means that once someone inserts the disk, the machine only ask for minimal information and all drivers, components, and optimizations are selected by default. Dell could do this for minimal cost and satisfy very many people. By offering extra free software (at no cost to Dell) such as Open Office, GIMP (Image editing), Asterisk (does voice over ip, traditional telephony, and voice mail), Instant Messaging, etc. Dell could add value roughly at 10's of thousands of dollars in equivilant proprietary software. In addition Dell should write a custom program specific to each particular distribution that allows users to retrieve, install, and support drivers for new pieces of hardware.

By doing this, Dell could tremendously increase its sales for relatively little upfront costs. It will bring very good publicity to Dell - especially when consumers buy computers from other vendors which contain restrictive Microsoft Vista.

Dell lost a sale by not offering me pre-installed Linux. However, the next time I get ready to purchase a new computer, I will check to see if Dell offeres what I want for the right price. If so, I will be more than happy to buy.
stuartcampbell
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/26/07
Make sure things like external display switching works (i.e. Fn-F8) - it is the only thing that I have still got windows on my DELL laptop for...to give presentations!
vokado
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/27/07
Oh YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS !!!!!!!
andreyko
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/27/07
Knows somebody why d520 with freedos is more expensive then with winxp? $1,310 and $1,282

Intel® Core™ 2 Duo T7200 (2.00GHz) 4M L2 Cache, 667Mhz Dual Core
Genuine Windows XP Professional, SP2, with media
15 inch SXGA+ LCD Panel
1.0GB, DDR2-667 SDRAM, 1 DIMM
60GB Hard Drive, 9.5MM, 7200RPM
8X DVD+/-RW w/Sonic Digital Media™ and Cyberlink Power DVD™
Intel® 3945 802.11a/g Dual-band Mini Card
Dell Wireless® 350 Bluetooth Module

Intel® Core™ 2 Duo T7200 (2.00GHz) 4M L2 Cache, 667Mhz Dual Core
FreeDOS Operating System Kit
15 inch SXGA+ LCD Panel
1.0GB, DDR2-667 SDRAM, 1 DIMM
60GB Hard Drive, 9.5MM, 7200RPM
8X DVD+/-RW, Data Only
Intel® 3945 802.11a/g Dual-band Mini Card
Dell Wireless® 350 Bluetooth Module
conejoi
02/27/07
Merged Comment originally posted 02/27/07
I would like to have a laptop which works perfectly under Linux, meaning opensource drivers for all the devices.
majid
02/27/07
Merged Idea originally posted 02/17/07
Shoebox sized game system with a decent video card

Shuttle has great success making compact shoebox-size PCs with few compromises. I bought a gaming PC last week. I wanted a 8800GTX to run Oblivion at comfortable frame rates, and considered the XPS, but nothing at a reasonable price range. Shuttle has a shoebox with a 8800GTS for about $2000, it was quite tempting. The Dimension C521 has a very interesting form factor, but unfortunately a wimpy power supply. I ended up building one myself for about $1500, albeit using a regular sized case.

Don't assume all gamers are impressed by hulking big cases with flashing lights. For most purposes, a big box is just a waste of space, but we don't want underpowered graphics as the trade-off for a compact case.
kdubber
02/27/07
I think this makes a lot of sense for THEUninitiatied... they don't know what Windows does so get them STARTED on linux..it really isn't any harder than Windows..especially if pre installed.. firefox is so simple anyone can use it.. and so is linux.. Open Office is plenty powerful for the average person. So what is left for the majority of users of computers.. NOTHING.. ALL most people use a computer for is internet.. they don't NEED anything besides A good Linux distro with firefox and maybe Thunderbird. and what is the side benefit...NO COST FOR VIRUS PROTECTION.. Hmmm sounds like win win to me..and this would be the perfect place for Dell to start their own Linux distro... say "DeLLinux" simple inexpensive Internet primary use boxes.. MASS MARKET APPEAL..
Kent
ps..for more on DeLLinux start looking here; http://www.dellideastorm.com/article/show/63462/DeLLinux_
frednerk
02/27/07
I think you could seriously out style the Mac, fill a niche etc.

Maybe have the option where you get a basic box, no KB or Mouse or Monitor, with TV out set up (and/or the option of cordless). Have the Internet TV box that microsoft flopped in 1998.

Other thing I'd like to see is a tiny form factor cool media centre pc with linux. Save all the money by getting all the open source and free goodies out there and making something that will play DVDs, CD's through the telly, get stuff off the internet etc.
daveski
02/27/07
Excellent idea to have a super-simple, but must be super-cheap, mini PC. Sell this as an 'internet box' rather than a full desktop PC.
Please log in to post a comment
last 100 demotions: